← LearnPoints vs. cash

Points or Cash? How to Decide on Flights and Hotels

Last reviewed: September 28, 2026 · Reading time: about 6 minutes

The short answer: use points when a redemption gets you more value per point than your baseline (at least the roughly 1 cent per point most major transferable programs pay through their travel portals), and the booking is one you'd make anyway. Pay cash when the cash price is low, the points price is high, or paying cash earns you something you'd give up by redeeming. One formula does most of the work, and a few extra checks handle the rest.

This guide is for small-business owners whose cards earn a steady stream of points and who keep facing the same question at checkout: points or cash?

The one formula you need

Cents per point = (cash price − taxes and fees on the award) ÷ points required × 100

The result tells you what each point is "buying" on this booking. Compare it to a baseline:

The floor. Chase Ultimate Rewards®, Amex Membership Rewards®, Capital One miles and Citi ThankYou® points typically redeem for about 1 cent each through the issuer's travel portal, according to NerdWallet's 2026 valuations. If a redemption returns less than that, you could usually do better by booking the same trip through the portal, or by paying cash.
A benchmark. Published valuations give you a "typical" figure for each program. NerdWallet's 2026 median estimates, for example, put American AAdvantage at 1.7 cents, Southwest and JetBlue at 1.4 cents, Delta and United at 1.2 cents, World of Hyatt at 1.8 cents and Marriott Bonvoy at 0.7 cents. Treat these as reference points, not promises. For why different sources disagree, see How Much Are Business Credit Card Points Really Worth?.

If your redemption beats the benchmark for that currency, points are usually a good use. If it falls between the floor and the benchmark, it's a judgment call. If it's below the floor, lean toward cash.

Worked example 1: a family flight

Example only; prices are illustrative, not quotes. Four round-trip economy tickets cost $1,480 in cash. The same flights cost 90,000 miles plus $45 in taxes and fees.

($1,480 − $45) ÷ 90,000 × 100 ≈ 1.59 cents per mile

That's above the 1-cent floor and above a 1.2-cent benchmark for a program like United or Delta. Points look like a good choice here.

Now suppose a fare sale drops the cash price to $720, while the award price stays at 90,000 miles:

($720 − $45) ÷ 90,000 × 100 = 0.75 cents per mile

Same trip, same miles, but now cash is clearly better. That's why you should run the numbers each time instead of assuming points are always "free."

Worked example 2: a hotel stay

Example only. A room with two queen beds costs $260 a night in cash, including taxes. The award price is 40,000 points a night in a hotel program.

$260 ÷ 40,000 × 100 = 0.65 cents per point

Whether that's good depends on the program. It sits a little under NerdWallet's 0.7-cent median for Marriott, and far below its 1.8-cent median for Hyatt. If those were Hyatt points, you'd probably pay cash and keep them. If they're points you can only use at that chain, and you have no better plan for them, a near-median redemption may be perfectly reasonable.

The takeaway is to compare each redemption against the currency you're spending, not against a single number for all points.

Five things the formula doesn't capture

1. What you'd earn by paying cash. A cash booking may earn airline miles, hotel points, elite credit and card rewards. An award booking often earns fewer or none of those, though the rules vary by program and portal bookings are often treated like paid bookings. If paying cash earns you a meaningful amount back, subtract that from the cash price before you compare.

2. Flexibility and cancellation. Some award bookings can be cancelled with the points returned; some cheap cash fares can't be changed at all. Portal bookings follow the portal's rules. A slightly weaker redemption that's refundable can be worth more to a family whose plans might change.

3. Scarcity of the points you're spending. If you hold 300,000 points in one program and 15,000 in another, the smaller balance is harder to replace. It's reasonable to protect a scarce currency and spend the plentiful one.

4. The cost of waiting. Points don't earn interest, and programs change. In 2026, award nights at approximately 95% of Marriott properties became more expensive, and Hyatt restructured its award chart, according to NerdWallet. A "good" redemption available today can beat a theoretical "great" one next year. We cover this trade-off in Should You Save Your Credit Card Points or Use Them Now?

5. Whether you'd actually pay that cash price. Cents-per-point math assumes the cash price is the real alternative. If you'd never buy a $6,000 business-class ticket, redeeming for one doesn't "save" you $6,000. Compare against what you would realistically have paid.

Mixing points and cash

You don't have to pick one currency for the whole trip. Many families use points for the part of the trip with the best value, often flights at peak times, and pay cash for the rest. Some issuers also let you cover part of a portal booking with points and the rest with your card, so you can use a partial balance without waiting.

A simple approach:

Price every piece of the trip in cash: flights, hotel, car.
Price each piece in points.
Calculate cents per point for each piece.
Spend points on the pieces with the highest value, and pay cash for the rest.

For a full planning walkthrough, see How to Plan a Family Vacation With Business Credit Card Points.

A quick decision checklist

I compared against the all-in cash price for the exact flights or room I'd book.
I subtracted award taxes and fees before dividing.
My result beats the 1-cent portal floor.
I compared it to a benchmark for this currency.
I considered what paying cash would earn back.
I know the cancellation rules for both options.
If I'm transferring points, I confirmed award availability first, because transfers are generally one-way.

How Points Compass fits in

Doing this math at checkout is tedious, especially for four travelers. Points Compass does it for you. You type in your balances and your trip's price in both points and cash (no bank or loyalty logins), and the app compares the redemption with a cents-per-point baseline you can edit, then gives a plain verdict on whether points or cash is the better way to pay. It also estimates what waiting may cost if you're still earning toward the trip. The free plan covers one complete trip. Download on theApp Store.

FAQ

Is it better to use points or cash for flights? It depends on the specific fare. Divide the cash price (minus award taxes and fees) by the miles required. If the result beats your baseline for that program, points are usually the better choice. Cheap cash fares often make points a poor deal.

What is a good cents-per-point value? Anything below about 1 cent is usually weak for major transferable points, because that's roughly what portals pay. Beyond that, "good" depends on the program. Compare against a dated, published benchmark for the currency you're spending.

Should I use points for hotels or flights? Whichever gives you more value per point on your trip. Run the formula for both. Hotel point values vary widely by program, so a hotel redemption that's fine for one chain can be poor for another.

Do I earn miles on award tickets? Often not, but it depends on the program and how you book. Portal bookings paid with points are frequently treated like paid bookings. Check the program's rules if earning matters to you.

Is there a points vs. cash calculator? Several websites offer one, and the formula above works with any calculator. Points Compass runs this comparison inside a trip plan, using balances you enter by hand.